Worker errors blamed for fatal crane collapse

Grant Prior 11 hours ago
Share

Staff errors were to blame for the collapse of a crane which killed three men on a site in Cheshire eight years ago, an inquest has found.

construction,coroner,crane,collapse,falcon,deaths
construction,coroner,crane,collapse,falcon,deaths

Rhys Barker, 18, David Newall, 36, and David Webb, 43, died after the incident at a building site in Crewe on 21 June 2017.

The BBC reported last week that a coroner concluded their deaths were an accident and the collapse was caused by a “series of errors” made by employees at Falcon Tower Crane Services Ltd.

The firm, which was acquitted last year after being charged with health and safety breaches, said it had co-operated fully with all authorities and its thoughts remained with the families.

The three men were working as part of a team to erect the Potain MC85B tower crane at a building site on Dunwoody Way when it tilted and fell.

It collapsed onto two homes adjacent to the site but none of the occupants were injured.

In her conclusion at Cheshire Coroner’s Court, senior coroner Jacqueline Devonish said there were mistakes made in preparing documents outlining how the crane should be set up.

She wrote in her record of inquest: “The cause of the crane collapse was due to a series of errors by Falcon Crane Services Ltd staff members with responsibilities for drafting the method statement and associated documents, which contained an incorrect sequence of works by omitting the crucial requirement for partial ballasts.”

Devonish said the error was not identified and the supervisor “compounded this when he did not correctly follow the build plan and sequence for the work”.

This culminated in the overbalancing of the crane, she said, without the “crucial partial ballasts”.

Devonish added” “The change in process caused the jib to slew in the opposite direction to that planned, therefore endangering the local community when the crane fell onto two residential homes outside the site.

She gave a conclusion of accidental death “contributed to by a chain of errors in producing the method statement and absence of partial ballast”.

Following the inquest’s conclusion, a spokesperson for Falcon Cranes told the BBC it had been “deeply affected” by the incident and had done all it can to provide support to the families.

They said the firm had co-operated fully with all authorities “throughout long and detailed investigations”.

The spokesperson said: “We hope this process and the conclusion reached by the coroner following long and detailed investigations will assist the families and all others concerned to achieve a degree of closure in relation to the deaths.

“Our thoughts remain with the families and all others who have suffered as a consequence of this tragic accident.”

In November 2024, Falcon Tower Cranes Services was acquitted of two health and safety breaches after a judge directed the jury to return not guilty verdicts, due to insufficient evidence.

Latest news

Worker errors blamed for fatal crane collapse

Coroner delivers verdict over accident which killed three men
11 hours ago

Wates, Morgan Sindall and Fortem land places on £1bn SEC deal

10 firms win homes decarbonising deal across London and the South East
11 hours ago

Buyers report slowdown in construction decline

Contraction continues across all sectors
16 hours ago

HSS to pay private equity £26m to buy hire arm

The sell-off comes as HSS reported a £130m loss
19 hours ago

Menai Bridge closed over bolt safety fears

Welsh government "incredibly frustrated" after latest advice from maintenance engineers
19 hours ago

New owner for offsite specialist McAvoy

Investor Duke Street takes control at modular contractor
18 hours ago

Bouygues bags £51m Hillingdon college job

Total revamp for Rosedale College
19 hours ago

Kier lands £29m Southern Water ECI deal

Framework win covers 11 clean and wastewater sites across the South East
19 hours ago

Sellafield construction strike action escalates

1,500 construction workers stage latest round of industrial action
4 days ago

Water company fines to fund local restoration schemes

£10m in penalties will go towards local renovation projects
19 hours ago

Staycity plans London Blackfriars 25-storey aparthotel

Developer Citygrove will start construction in 2027
4 days ago

William Hare snaps at rival Severfield’s heels after growth spurt

Turnover jumps a third to £423m while margin hits 7.9%
4 days ago

Go-ahead for Bolton £100m Church Wharf regeneration

Developer Watson to start this year on over 400 homes and 130-bed hotel
4 days ago

Contractors primed for £596m Westminster housing works

London council to overhaul repairs and major works deals under new alliance model
4 days ago

Green light for £69m retrofit of Edinburgh housing blocks

Cables Wynd House and Linksview House to be transformed
5 days ago

“Insider video” tour shows Hinkley construction progress

Watch latest film from giant site
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall profits to smash forecasts again as fit-out booms

Order book climbs to £12.2bn as net cash tops £350m
5 days ago

Skanska clears consent for £345m A46 Newark Bypass

Work to start major upgrade of Midlands freight route next year
5 days ago

Edinburgh awards £61m fire safety upgrade deal

Specialist Harmony Fire will work on 30 multi-storey resi buildings across the city
5 days ago
Harmony Fire

World’s first hydrogen digger starts prep for Thames Crossing

Hopes grow for a 2026 start on Lower Thames Crossing
5 days ago

Bovis bags £237m East Midlands army barracks upgrade

Work to start this autumn at Kendrew Barracks and Bulwell Army Reserve Centre
5 days ago

25 firms land places on £250m Guinness safety framework

Framework covers cladding, fire doors, structural repairs and façade upgrades
5 days ago

Profits double at Red Construction

Contractor eyes expansion in East of England and the Midlands
5 days ago

700 housing schemes stalled in S106 affordable uptake crisis

Ninety house builders call for urgent action as 8,500 homes in limbo as providers walk away
6 days ago

HSS shares suspended over accounts delay

Hire giant misses deadline to file latest numbers
6 days ago

Brickie’s crippling accident inspires wall safety invention

Carl Harris turns wall collapse ordeal into life-saving wall bracing system
6 days ago

Heathrow maps out M25 build plan under third runway – video

Airport reveals offline tunnel and bridge scheme to keep motorists moving
6 days ago

Green light for 31-storey Fenchurch Street tower

Demolition work to start next year on latest City of London office scheme
7 days ago

Gilbert-Ash profit doubles as employee ownership beds in

Profitability improves as revenue slips back 10% to £236m
6 days ago

Architect appointed interim Chief Construction Adviser

Thouria Istephan takes up pivotal role on building safety reforms
6 days ago